Prints comparisons and 100.000 Pageviews! :D

9 min read

Deviation Actions

NEOkeitaro's avatar
By
Published:
31.4K Views
Trying out the new journal, bare with me...

Exploring the prints offering from DeviantART
It's been a while I've been meaning to write this journal...

A few months ago, I realized I had earned enough money by selling my prints on deviantART to actually buy some! (Thank you all, by the way) But then I realized I never saw what my deviations actually render as prints. As someone who is spending a lot of time and money to make the most high quality pictures I can, it made me quite uneasy to sell prints that not only I don't have any control on, but that I've never even seen. So, I decided to use the money I earned to actually buy my OWN prints to check if the quality was ok...

I decided to buy a print of one of my favorite deviation, which also happens to be one of my most irreproachable, technically, La Scala di Momo. This picture has been taken with an awesome lens with low ISO, and I've spent literally hours fine tuning the black and white conversion, and especially the gradients of grey, making no less than 8 different versions, using different softwares and processes until I was happy with what I got. Needless to say, I know this picture very well, having analyzed it at pixel level on my calibrated screen for long, long hours.

La Scala Di Momo by NEOkeitaro

The Review


I bought all the versions that made sense to buy: the fine art version, and the print version in glossy, lustre and matte, as well as postcards, which were supposed to look great, as they are printed on actual photo paper. 

I was interested in several things: color and contrast accuracy, sharpness, and texture. This picture, on screen, has a sense of depth, which I expected to be even more pronounced on print. 

My first observation, for every kind of prints, is that this sense of depth is not really there, or at least, not accentuated by prints. Now, it doesn't mean the prints are bad, but they just don't make you "WOW" when you see them. Opening the packages, I was a bit underwhelmed. 

Something else became noticeable very quickly: every prints look very, very different. 
_MG_0470.jpg by NEOkeitaro
Matte postcard, glossy postcard, Matte, Lustre, Glossy print, and fine art under it all


Even in pictures, the difference is quite striking. Now, of course, this is to be expected: each version has its qualities. None, however, resemble the picture on screen. They mostly look faded, or too contrasty. The fine art clearly had the finer gradients, but it just looks like the gamma was raised: it's just too bright. The postcards are the most contrasted of all, although the matte one does actually look rather good in person. 

The textures change a lot as well, of course. I took close up pictures so you could see: 


_MG_0458.jpg by NEOkeitaro  _MG_0461.jpg by NEOkeitaro(the glossy)
_MG_0459.jpg by NEOkeitaro (the matte)
_MG_0464.jpg by NEOkeitaro _MG_0462.jpg by NEOkeitaro(the lustre)
_MG_0452.jpg by NEOkeitaro(the fine art)

The photo prints are quite porous and gather dust very quickly. The fine art, however, has quite large "paper grain", that is very different from the prints: it really reflects light like paper from a book would, rather than being any kind of shiny surface. It feels natural, yet very... "flat". To be perfectly honest I wasn't overly impressed by the fine art print.

A word of caution
The prints come in tubes. If you don't pay for express shipping, it takes two to three weeks to arrive, which is a bit slow but within the norms. However, this actually poses a problem when you ordered big prints. I ordered the highest size of fine art print for this deviation (not shown here, it's HUGE). First, they sent me the wrong picture (funny story actually: they sent me a picture in black and white of a spiral stair, but it wasn't my picture! I sent them a message and they sent the right one for free, immediately. Good service!), and finally I received mine, carefully wrapped in bubble wrap (I guess there isn't a tube big enough for this kind of print...). I didn't order a frame because this picture doesn't actually have any black in it, and a black frame would only accentuate the fact that it's a bit faded. So I wanted to have a frame custom made, in France...

However, this didn't happen: when I went to see a professional to frame my picture, he refused to take it: the print had been folded for too long and could not be held flat (we were about to stretch it and glue it to a hard surface, but even then you have to make sure you can make the picture flat at some point...). So be careful: either buy the picture framed so it is actually flat, or ask for a speedier shipping, as if it waits too long in its package, your print will effectively unusable... I learnt it the hard way...

In Conclusion...
All in all I'm a bit underwhelmed by the quality of the prints offered on deviantART. I've always been on the impression that they were some of the best you could get, and that buying a print on deviantART, thanks to their careful screening process, was an assurance of good quality. While I wouldn't say the prints I received were of bad quality per se, they are not as impressive as I hope they would be. 

I understand of course that this test was only for one picture, and in black and white (and not the easiest tones either... This picture is very, very precise in its tones, any screw up is pretty obvious) so maybe in color, or another kind of medium, would look awesome. I've heard very good reviews of deviantART prints after all. I'm actually sorry I can't add to this stream of glowing reviews. 

I hope it has been useful to you, and don't let it discourage you from buying me prints, they do look good and are good value for the price! :D

In other words... 100.000 PAGEVIEWS!!
Last week I have reached 100.000 pageviews (and the 100.000th was... me! :D). Thank you everyone, deviantART has been a big part of my life for nearly a decade, it completely changed my life and I wouldn't be where I am today, and not as happy as I am now, if it wasn't for this site. This website was and still is a great community, which I'm very proud to be a member of.

I hope you're all alright, I would love to hear more from you, what music you're listening to lately, your plans for the summer... I'm actually shooting a feature film in Monaco this summer, you'll know more about it soon! :D

I love you all :)





© 2013 - 2024 NEOkeitaro
Comments2
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
Boredman's avatar
"I ordered the highest size of fine art print for this deviation (not shown here, it's HUGE).
First, they sent me the wrong picture (funny story actually...
"

Pendant un instant, j'ai imaginé ce qui se serait passé s'ils t'avaient envoyé un autre boulot à toi par erreur... tu sais, le genre de truc qui ferait VRAIMENT mal aux yeux imprimé en très grand...

Genre ça [link] XD

Félicitations en tout cas ! Quatre zéro c'est bien, mais cinq c'est mieux :party: